The Goblet by Ulric Daubeny
“The Goblet” is a short story by Ulric Daubeny. It was first published in the April 1919 issue of The Premier Magazine. It has since been republished in the Ulric Daubeny anthology The Elemental: Tales of the Supernormal and the Inexplicable. The anthology was first published in 1919 by George Routledge & Sons. It has since been reprinted by several other publishers, including Ash-Tree Press (2006), Black Heath Editions (2019), and Solar Press (2023). Some publishers include “The Goblet,” while others do not. The story does not appear to have been present in original anthology.
About Ulric Daubeny
Ulric Evan Daubeny (1888 — 1922) is an obscure British horror author many fans of the genre may not be familiar with. Information about him is lacking.
Daubeny only wrote one anthology of supernatural fiction—The Elemental: Tales of the Supernormal and the Inexplicable. He also wrote at least one other book called Ancient Cotswold Churches (1923), which he dedicated to his wife. The book contained pen and ink illustrations provided by Cecily Daubeny. Although Cecily may have been another family member, it seems likely she was his wife.
Daubney’s most successful work of fiction is “The Sumach“—a story about a vampire tree. It has been anthologized several times and was translated into Italian for the anthology IL Sangue e la Rosa (1988).
The Goblet
by Ulric Daubeny
(Online Text)
I had this from de Haviland between the acts of a wearisome first production at the Frivolity. It is here confessed that his story interested me far more than did the play; in fact I retain not the smallest recollection of the concluding acts. My thoughts were centred on De Haviland and his extraordinary experiences with the goblet, and, even now, I seem no nearer to a satisfactory explanation.
Is it possible that insensate articles can carry with them, and, under certain circumstances, transmit, memories of former vivid associations? Or—if the goblet were indeed counterfeit—could some similar mysterious principle hold good with respect to the foreshadowing of future happenings? Both theories are equally improbable, yet to reject them would seem to side-track the question to one of reincarnation, and so complete the mystic circle. Certain it is that neither nerves nor “liver” had any share in these strange happenings: the merest sight of De Haviland would convince anyone of that. Besides, there is his wife to be taken into consideration.
Now to come to the story.
* * *
Last summer, you remember, was held poor Albeny’s sale. I wanted some memento and had decided on a handsome silver goblet, considerably prized by him, for he had won it at a Cowes Regatta. The lot would be put up for sale after lunch, the clerk assured me on the view day, and I should have been there in ample time, had not a puncture considerably delayed me on the road. As it happened, I was just edging my way into the crowded room, when the auctioneer’s voice called out, preparatory to the fall of the hammer:
“Two hundred and seven, going at nine pounds!”
“Nine-five!” I shouted, almost from the doorway; and then the bidding commenced anew, for several local dealers, jealous of anyone outside “the trade” forced me to the uttermost farthing. In fact, the goblet fetched considerably more than I had anticipated, but, for the sake of our old friendship, I did not for a moment grudge the extra money.
The lot knocked down,[1] I immediately left the building, for it pained me to see the rooms, still so eloquent of my friend, thrown open to the curious mob. Next morning, cheque in hand, I called to fetch away my purchase, but instead of the Cowes goblet, they pointed to another.
“That’s not mine,” I remarked to the clerk in charge. “I bought the yachting cup, lot two hundred and seven.”
“Two hundred and seven was the yachting cup, sir, but your name stands against lot two hundred and eleven.”
And he pointed to the catalogue:
211. Embossed silver Goblet; reproduction of antique Italian work—Mr De Haviland.
I knew exactly what had happened. My late arrival, my tendency to deafness, had led me to mistake the number, so I was left with the “reproduction of antique Italian work,” a sorry enough memento, for I had never before set eyes upon it, nor indeed, was I aware that Alenbey possessed such a piece of plate.
As perhaps was natural, I took rather a dislike to the thing; nobody could call me fanciful, but its very appearance filled me with antipathy. Afterwards the feeling dulled, and I just tolerated it. It was handsome enough in its way, the bowl embossed with classic figures, supported on a twisted stem with curious base. This latter took the form of a satyr’s face, leering and horrible, peeping out from an aureole of beard and hair, like Bellona’s head, the stem rising from between the snarling, sensual lips.
On reaching home, I placed my purchase in a position of honour upon the sideboard, and I can recall no further interest in it until one September afternoon, when I came in hot from gardening, and took a bottle of cider from the cellar, carrying it up to the dining room to open. Now, cider should be drawn only from a silver tankard or a china mug—never out of glass—and the handiest silver being the Italian goblet, I filled it to the brim with the delicious, amber-coloured liquid. Still standing, I lifted it slowly to my lips. But, oh, the taste! It was acid and bitter; it parched my mouth and burnt into my throat like a fiery stream. Objects commenced to blur before my vision, and in agony I staggered backwards—suddenly to recover, and find myself standing quietly by the sideboard, the goblet against my lips, as if still about to sip!
You may guess I put the drink down pretty quickly, upsetting a little in the movement, for my hand still shook. It was a curious sensation, but passed almost at once, and, in truth, I thought very little more about it. The cider must have turned unusually sour, and so ruminating I poured the rest away, though later it transpired that the other bottles were in excellent condition.
My next vivid recollection of the goblet was at a little dinner given to Marianne Bridgman, in celebration of our engagement. No doubt with a wish to pay all possible honour to the occasion, my servants had placed upon the table a considerable quantity of plate, and among it was the Italian goblet, immediately in front of me. Towards the end of dinner, its striking appearance, its almost devilish ingenuity of design, became the subject of several interested comments, and for the first time it began to breed in me something of a pride of ownership.
Such feelings, no doubt, provoked me to have it filled with wine, and so for the second time, in a somewhat ostentatious manner, I raised the goblet in my hand. Hardly had it reached my mouth than Marianne, springing suddenly forward, made a frenzied grab at my uplifted arm, causing the whole contents of the goblet to splash against my shirt front and on to the gleaming tablecloth. Our glances met, and for the space of a second I read in her eyes a look of blank, unreasoning terror, quickly to be replaced by one of dazed astonishment. The poor girl seemed to shrink into herself, and, burying her face in her hands, gave herself up to a fit of sobbing. Everyone was thunderstruck. Of course, personally, I was particularly upset, for only a moment earlier Marianne and I had been quietly talking.
Mrs Bridgman rose, and led her daughter from the room, and their departure signalled a general break up of the diners. Marianne returned shortly to the drawing room, pale but perfectly composed, and offered a pretty apology to me, and to the company in general.
“I cannot imagine what made me do it,” she confided, when I had taken her aside. “The action was quite involuntary; for a moment I had a dreadful fear to see you drinking. I am most horribly ashamed of my exhibition. Philip, you must not think that it is usual for me to have these nervous outbreaks; never has such a thing happened to me before.”
Nevertheless, my feeling of anxiety continued for several days, for I feared that the excitement of the engagement, and the trials of trousseau hunting, were making Marianne ill, but she continued in her usual spirits, and so, by degrees, the incident came to be forgotten.
Shortly before my marriage, I received a flying visit from Bancroft, home for a short breathing space between his marvellous Asian travels. He arrived at lunchtime, and hardly had we entered the dining room than he spotted the goblet in its accustomed place on the sideboard. With the collector’s natural unconcern, he crossed the room, and made at it with what almost amounted to a greedy snatch.
“Where the deuce did you pick up this. De Haviland?” he queried, facing round in an excited manner.
“Bought it at Alenbey’s sale, in mistake for—”
“Thought as much!” he interrupted, in his usual bluff way. “My own fault, I admit, but—I’d like to hang the auctioneer who put such an article into a wretched little local sale.” And he fingered the goblet lovingly.
Of course, I was completely in the dark, but, knowing my Bancroft exceeding well, I waited patiently until, in the fullness of time, it should please him to continue.
During several seconds he gazed at it in a silent ecstasy of admiration, and then, noticing my bewildered look, proceeded to explain.
“This rightly belongs to me,” he said, affectionately flipping the goblet, causing it to emit a silvery ring. “I asked Alenbey to keep it whilst I was away in Persia, and together we placed it in his safe; but neither thought of attaching any paper, or a label. I neglected to write about it when the news of his death reached me, so, naturally, it was counted with his other property. Now what—what in the name of all that is abominable, did they call it in the sale catalogue?”
“A ‘reproduction of antique Italian work.’ ”
“Reproduction be hanged!” Bancroft cried indignantly. “Man, do you know that you’ve got here, a genuine Borgia cup, a memento, very probably, of one of their skilfully planned poison entertainments?”
I was not impressed—not pleasurably, that is, for I could never appreciate the glamour of romance with which it is customary to surround mediaeval criminals, even if they did happen to be popes and princes. With this revelation of its past associations, much of my original dislike for the goblet returned. I felt that its fit position would be in a criminal museum, though I dare not moot such treasonable sentiments to the worshipping collector. It ended by Bancroft taking the wretched cup away with him. Clearly it was his by right. so I allowed him to refund the money it had realized at the sale, and we said no more about it. To tell the truth, I was thankful to be rid of the thing, for not only was its history rather gruesome, but my own experiences with it had been the reverse of pleasant—somewhat uncanny, in fact, examined under the light of this fresh knowledge. Imagine my feelings, therefore, when, a fortnight later, the cup came back, together with an apologetic note from Bancroft:
“It was disgustingly mean of me to take the Borgia cup,” the letter commenced abruptly. “You must think that I have allowed my collector’s passion to stride all ordinary feelings of decency and fairness. Now, quite apart from a natural desire to repair a wrong, I feel that I should like you to accept it as a wedding present, and I trust that you will do so, together with my heartiest congratulations.
“As I recently explained, the goblet is of peculiar rarity and interest for its association with the Borgias, certain records proving it to have been specially designed for Catherine of that name. I hear that a copy is preserved in the Vatican Museum, and, when next in Rome, I shall make a point of seeing it, and will post you regarding any additional particulars it may be possible to discover.
“By the time this reaches you I shall once more be on my travels, expecting to remain away for at least a year.”
And so the goblet had returned to roost, and with it came a renewed sensation of abhorrence, of inexplicable repugnance whenever I set eyes upon it. Marianne was quite disturbed when she learnt of its reappearance, and when I had told her of the goblet’s history, she vowed she could never feel at ease with such an ill-omened possession in the house. Then a somewhat disgraceful idea came to me. Nixon, the big local jeweller, was possessed of a particularly handsome Queen Anne tea service, upon which Marianne and I had cast longing eyes, but, alas! it was beyond our pockets. The notion suggested itself of effecting an exchange for the Borgia cup.
I knew it was hardly the thing to do, even in view of our mutual dislike for our present, and it was only the knowledge of Bancroft’s amazing passion for the silver of this period that permitted me seriously to contemplate the transaction. This service, I assured myself, he would apprise even above the Borgia goblet, so, with many an inward misgiving, I broached the subject to my old tenant, Mr Nixon, who immediately raised adoring palms above the evil historical antique. The exchange was immediately effected, to the undisguised satisfaction of both parties, and shortly afterwards we were married, and, as you remember, set out for our honeymoon on the Continent.
We did not return for several months and on reaching home were not surprised to find a considerable accumulation of correspondence, as well as a formidable array of parcels, for the most part belated wedding gifts. The latter, of course, were calculated to appeal particularly to Marianne’s curiosity, so I begged her to open everything, irrespective of address. Hardly had I laid down my hat and taken off my coat, than I heard the snap of broken string and the rustle of soft paper, followed by a startled cry from Marianne.
“What is the matter?” I called out from the adjoining room.
“The—the Oh, Philip, do come and look!”
Something in her voice was not to be ignored, so I hastily went into the drawing room, to find her holding a burnished silver object at arm’s length. It was the Borgia cup!
We found a letter amongst the wrappings, explaining that poor Nixon’s firm was faced with bankruptcy. The ruin seemed complete; and as arrears of rent were heavy, the honest little man had returned to me the goblet, explaining that it had become his own private property, and so could not be claimed in payment of the company’s debts. For his sake, I felt disinclined to accept it; but on making inquiries it transpired that he had left town, and nobody knew anything of his present whereabouts.
Once again, therefore, we were saddled with the goblet. For some time the matter lapsed from memory, everything having become subservient to the joy of settling in our home; and then one day Marianne had a brilliant inspiration.
The corporation were advertising the town museum, soliciting gifts of historic or artistic interest. Why not offer them the Borgia goblet? The idea was most acceptable, and I personally carried the treasure to the museum, and interviewed the curator as to its disposal. He was overwhelming in his expressions of delight; he would design for it a special case, it should be raised upon an ebony stand, a descriptive card should be prepared. Meanwhile, this most precious object must be deposited in the safe, pending arrangements for its suitable exhibition.
Two days later, owing to the fusing of some wires, the museum was entirely gutted, the whole contents being destroyed, with the exception of course of the fireproof safe. In it was snugly stowed the Borgia goblet, and this, after a delay of several weeks, the corporation returned to me, it having been decided to abandon further plans for a museum, owing to a lack of funds.
Thus, for the third time, our unwelcome gift came back to us, despite the fact that, upon each occasion of its departure, we had bidden it a grateful and a permanent farewell. Twice I had been about to drink from it, but each time something happened to prevent me doing so; it now remains to tell of my third and absolutely last attempt.
When the goblet once more came into our possession the repugnance with which we used to view its presence had given place to a mere passive disregard, and if we did not actually welcome its return, at least it was received with some degree of mild relief. For the months were passing, and Bancroft might at any time come down upon us, perhaps with further scandalous details of the goblet’s history. It seemed ridiculous to hide the thing away; so, by tacit consent, it became restored to its old position upon the dining room sideboard.
September came once more, and with it the usual horticultural labours attendant on getting the garden into its winter dress. Marianne had just discovered a particularly virulent brand of weed poison, and was indulging her passion in every conceivable direction, using half the pots and pans in the house for the mixing and distribution of the noxious fluid. Towards the end of one more than usually strenuous afternoon, Marianne ruthlessly poisoning the weeds and I digging, she came upon me unawares, busily mopping at my heated face.
“Poor old boy,” she condoled, half comically. “So hot and tired! I am going to open a bottle of cider for you, and you must come into the dining room and drink it.”
Nothing loth, I carefully scraped the mud off my boots, and strolled leisurely towards the house. A cider bottle, already opened, stood invitingly upon the dining room table, and casting about the room, my eyes lighted upon the Italian goblet, glinting maliciously at me from its position of honour upon the sideboard. It was the very thing I wanted, so, crossing the room, I took it up, and filled it to the brim with the delicious, amber-coloured liquid. Still standing, I lifted it slowly to my lips—but at that moment Marianne entered, another bottle in her hand.
For the fraction of a second our glances met, and then, springing suddenly forward, she made a frenzied grab at my uplifted arm, causing the whole contents of the goblet to splash against my shirt front.
‘Philip, that was weed killer!’ she managed to gasp, white with terror; and seeing the unopened bottle in her hand, I understood.
Suddenly an unreasoning lust of anger against the goblet seized me, and dashing the hated object to the floor, I crushed it viciously beneath my heel, until its sinuous beauty had become a twisted, shapeless, mass. Then I snatched it up, and with a muttered imprecation, tossed it into the fire.
Marianne, still pale and trembling, drew up to my side and gently kissed me. “Thank Heaven you did that, Philip!” she whispered. “There was always something wicked, something horrible about that goblet.” And with a vindictive energy I never knew her to possess, she plunged her foot into the fire and trod the accursed goblet down among the flaming coals.
Arm in arm we watched it melt and disappear. At last, and for ever, there was an end of this Borgia goblet!
* * *
De Haviland ceased speaking and for several minutes we smoked our cigarettes and sipped our pegs in silence.
“An extraordinary chain of events!” I ventured presently. “And to give the credit wholly to coincidence would stretch that ‘long arm’ beyond all reasonable limits. Do you imagine that the goblet, constructed for an evil purpose, could have carried with it some mysterious legacy of evil?”
“Read that,” responded De Haviland, drawing an envelope from his pocket. “It came this afternoon, and that is what recalled the affair so vividly and prompted me to speak.”
The note was brief and hurried, written on foreign notepaper, with the heading simply, “Rome”:
My Dear De Haviland—Today in accordance with my promise made to you some time ago, I visited the Vatican Museum.
The Borgia cup, an exact replica of your own, proves to be a genuine original, not a copy. Is it possible that I was mistaken in the other goblet? I can hardly think so, yet the occurrence of two originals (duplicates) would perhaps be still more improbable.
I have decided to return at once, partly from a desire to satisfy my curiosity on this most unlooked-for point. Meanwhile, my dear De Haviland, you must please regard your specimen as doubtful; to me, the betting would appear to be about even either way.
—Your friend, BANCROFT.
Ulric Daubeny (1888 — 1922)
_________________________________
1. When used in relation to an auction, the phrase “Knocked down” means “sold.” The origin of the term is simple: the auctioneer finalizes an item’s sale to the winning bidder with a loud knock of his gavel. ↩
_________________________________
